    
 

 


 
                 .          . ,         ,         ,         .

    ,     ,   , ,   ,     .





 ,  

    



 GiegerichW., God must not die!, 2020

 MogensonG., Jungian analysis post mortem dei, 2021

 .., , , 2026

    , 2026


* * *




 


,     ,     ,     .           ,         . ,     ,      ,          /    .

 ,    ,   .        ,     .    , .         ,       .                 .  ,              ,       (the discipline of interiority).           :     .        ,   ,   -      -,   - , .     ( )  .               ,    [1 - Giegerich W. The Souls Logical Life. Peter Lang, 2007. P. 97.].           .   ,             ,     ,          .     ,    ,   [2 -        . .].

,               .    ?            ?         ?             (      ):    ,      ,      , ..  [3 -  ..  . .: +, 2006. C. 111.].       ,         (    )   . ,   ,  ,            [4 - Bishop P. Jungs answer to Job: acommentary. Routledge, 2002. P. 18.],          .           -  ,  .          ,      ,        .

     ,            .     ?           ? ,  ,   ,   ,    , ,        ,      .

   ..:     ;       ,      ,     [5 -  ..      . .: , 2013. C. 5.].


?

      .         .         .        (    )  ,      .          . ...




 

  post mortem Dei[6 - Mogenson G. Jungian Analysis Post Mortem Dei. Dusk Owl Books, 2021.]





 1


  ,   ; ,    ,     ;  ,     .

. 16:7




  


     ,    ,     .   ,     :     ,  ,  .     ,        .             ,     -    . ,   ,        -  .  ,  ,            ,  ,   ,      .   ,     :     ?

   ..    ,  ,          .     ,    --  1959        .     ,     , 85-  .        . ,  , :  .    .  [7 - BBC Television: Face to Face. Broadcast October 22, 1959 // McGuire W. & Hull R.F.C. (eds.). C.G. Jung Speaking: Interviews and Encounters. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1977. P. 428.].

  .   ,      .  ,      , -      : ,    ,         .

  .          .       ,               ,  ,    ,   .             .   ,      1935 ,     ,     :         ,         :      [8 -  ..  . .: -; .: , 1998. . 158.].              ,   :     ,   ,           ?

, , ,  .   ,     ,   ,  ,    ,     :



   ,     . ,       ,    ,  .       ,  ,      .  ,  . <>    ,  ,       ,     .      ,      ,    ,    .     ,       .      [9 - McGuire W. & Hull R.F.C. (eds.). C.G. Jung Speaking. P. 249250.].


 ,        .         .        ,    .  ,   ,    ,    - .      ,         ,       [10 -      :      patiens  agens,    ,    ,   ,  ,          .  ,     ,     . <>     :    ( ..     //  . . 303).].  ,         ,          .     ,   ,  ,        ,     ,  ,    [11 -  .. , ,  [  ]. .: ; : , 1998. . 84.].

       .            .         ,   ,          ,    ,   ,    .  ,  ,       ,      .  ,    ,  ,    . , ,  ,  ,   ?




 


   ,     ,      ,    -  ,         ,   .   , ?         ,           ,    , ..    ,    [12 -  ..  . . 226227.].

,       ,  ,        .  ,   ,    ,    ,            ,      ,  ,   .

              ,  ,   ,     ,     ,      II  ,    :



 ,   ,  ,     , :  ,  ,  ,  ,  ; ,     ,    ,  ,     ,  ,      ,  ,      ,  ,      .      ,     ,   ,             [13 -  .. . .: , 2009. . 255256.].


           ,      ,   ,   ,        [14 -     ,      :   ;  , ,     ,         , ..  ,        .         .        ,      ,      ..,            ,       .   ,            ,     .      ,     ,      .               :  ,  ,     ,     ,     .            ( ..  . . 232233).].

   ,      ,      ?    ,  ,     -    唻,          ,  ,     ,    .    ,       .        ,   ,  ,         .



          .      ,              .        .   ,      ,     .    .             .     ,      , ..      .     , .. ,   ,          :  ,  [15 - . . 409.].





  ?


     ,           ,     .    , ,      .  ,  ,   ,       . ,      ,       .

,      1922        ,    -  , , ,      :



  ,                 ,   .  ,   : ,  ,   .       ![16 - Freud S. & Pfister O. Psychoanalysis and Faith: The Letters of Sigmund Freud and Oskar Pfister. London: Hogarth Press and the Institute of Psycho-Analysis, 1963. P. 8687.]


            .      ,       ,      ,         [17 -  .   //   . .: , 1995. . 392.]. , ,  .     ,      ,         .



,   ,    ,       .        ,     .      .          :    ,      ,            .      ,     , , , .            [18 - CW 18. 1505.].


                . ,        ,  ,  ,      ,    ,  ,        .   ,    ,  ,  ?   ,     ?    ,   ,    fa?on de parler,   ,   , .

 ,   ! , ,         ,   ,        .   ,     ,    ,        :



-  [ --]       ,    ,   ,        []  ,     .       ,  ,    ,    .    ,  . ,   :  .  :      ,  .    ,       (, , ,    ..),   ,     ,            in consensu omnium (quod semper, quod ubique, quod ab omnibus creditur)[19 - Letters of C.G. Jung: Vol. 2, 19511961. Routledge, 1976. P. 525, to M. Leonard, 5 Dec. 1959.].


             .   ,   ,     .  ,      .        -        ,      [20 -      ,      , ,          .  ,    ,    ,  :    ,    ,    ,      ,    : , .  ,    -  -  .           ,          .     ,        , ,      ,             (Letters 2. P. 525, to M. Leonard, 5 Dec. 1959).      1906     ,   :          ,    ; ,   ,  -,    셻 (CW 2. 895).   ,  ,          .     -,          ,      .        ,   ,    , ,   .     ,       -,     ,   .                 (Jaff A. Was C.G. Jung A Mystic? And Other Essays. Einsiedeln: Daimon Verlag, 1989. P. 89).].       , ,  ,        ,      ?

,   1955 ,            ,   : ,   ,           .     ,  .    .           ,   [21 - McGuire W. & Hull R.F.C. (eds.). C.G. Jung Speaking. P. 251.].  ,       ,   .                    ;  ,    !

   ?   /          ,         .      .     :  ,   .

 ,           ,           .    , ,   ,  ,      ,        -  .         .    ,        ,          ,   ,   ,   ,      :           .                     [22 -  ..    //   . .: , 1991. . 171. . :  .. Mysterium Coniunctionis. .: -; .: , 1997. . 584.].

      .   ,    ,  ,       .      .           ,       . , ,      .  ,           (, ,       ): coincidentia oppositorum         [23 - ,  :       ,   -      .               .     ,    ,       .  ,      , ,      .].




 


     ,           .      ,            ,      ,  ,        .     ,    ,      ,      ,       .  :               .

        .     ,      .         ?       ,         ?  :  ,         ,      ,   [24 -  ..     //   . . 100101.].        ,  ,    []    ,       ,      :



            ,     .         .            ,   .     ,     .                 .       ,        .      ,     [25 -  ..    . . 113114.].


 ,    ,      .      ,    ,      ,   ,   .              .      .           .   ,    ,    ,       ,    ,    .  ,   ,    , ,    ,        ,      .

    ? ,   ,         ,                    .   ,          .   ,         ,     .    ,           ,            ,     [26 -      .  : The Dove in the Consulting Room: Hysteria and the Anima in Bollas and Jung (Hove & New York: Brunner-Routledge, 2003).].

     ,  ,   ,       ,  []   [27 -  ..   . .:  , 2013. . 100.].          ,        ,      ,       .    ,    ,       . ,    ,     .

  .         :    ,        , ,     ,  ,    .     -   ,    [28 - McGuire W. (ed.). C.G. Jung, Notes of the Seminar Given in 1925. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1989. P. 111.].  ,               :                  ,     [29 -  ..       //  . . 58.].      .       ,       ,         ,     ,  :         ,       [  ],       [30 - . . 404.]. , ,        -.      ,     ,   ,     ,                 (. 16:7).        ,            ,       ,      :



    , ,       ,      ,  .     ,    :  ,     .        , ..     ,     ,     ,    .      ,   ,  ,     ,         [31 -  ..      . . 79.].





 


             ,         .  , ,    ,    ,  ,            ?.       . ,     ,   ,    ,       ,      ,       .

, , ,       ,  .  , ,     ,    ,  ,   .     .  ,     .    ,        .

  ,       ,   .  ,       ,   ,    . -       ,     .           ,    ?     .      , , ,      ,     ,   ,   ,         . ,  ,    (  ),    .       ?       ?     ,         .      [32 - Jung C.G. The Red Book: Liber Novus / Ed. by S. Shamdasani. New York & London, W.W. Norton & Company, 2009. P. 329.],     .




Caveat redemptor


, !   ?       ,      ?       .  ,    .     ,       .   ,  ,        .        ?,  ,         ,   ( ,         ),        .  , ..  ,    , -  - ,   . ,                   ,   .         ,       ,  (      ) ,     in absentia dei[33 -    (.). . .], ,  ,         ,    post mortem dei[34 -    (.). . .].




 2


[ ]              ,     ,    .

..  




   !  ? ?


 , ,           ! (.    . 97 . .).      ,    ,       ,       .

,    ,       ,     ,             [35 -  ..    //    . .: , 2023. . 212.].  ,           .         ,  ,   ,      ,    [36 -  ..    //   :  . .; .: ; Port-Royal, 1997. . 96.].    ,    ,         !.     ,   ,   . ,    [37 - Giegerich W. The End of Meaning and the Birth of Man: An Essay about the State Reached in the History of Consciousness and an Analysis of C.G. Jungs Psychology Project // Journal of Jungian Theory and Practice. 2004. Vol. 6. 1. P. 38.],  ,    [     ]    셻[38 - CW 18. 632.].  ,  ,  ,     ,       .   , ,    .   ,        ,    .        ,  XIX  XX         . ,  , ,        .           [39 - . . 84.].                ,            .      ,       .           (  []    ),           [40 - CW 18. 632.].  ,    ,  , ,    ,  .

 ,        . ,                 ,   ,               .

 ,    ,     , ,           ,    ,   ,      [41 - White V. God and the Unconscious: An Encounter between Psychology and Religion. London & Glasgow: Fontana Books, 1960. P. 43.].          ,  ,      ,  :  ,        ,      ;   ;  ,      ;    ,   ,      .

     (      )? ,        ,     ?      ,  ,       .         ,       . ,   ,     ,        .    ,        ,      ,       , ,   ,     ,   ,    .        -       ,         .




  .


   .

   ,     (https://www.litres.ru/pages/biblio_book/?art=73869447)  .

      Visa, MasterCard, Maestro,    ,   ,     ,  PayPal, WebMoney, ., QIWI ,       .



notes








1


Giegerich W. The Souls Logical Life. Peter Lang, 2007. P. 97.




2


       . .




3


 ..  . .: +, 2006. C. 111.




4


Bishop P. Jungs answer to Job: acommentary. Routledge, 2002. P. 18.




5


 ..      . .: , 2013. C. 5.




6


Mogenson G. Jungian Analysis Post Mortem Dei. Dusk Owl Books, 2021.




7


BBC Television: Face to Face. Broadcast October 22, 1959 // McGuire W. & Hull R.F.C. (eds.). C.G. Jung Speaking: Interviews and Encounters. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1977. P. 428.




8


 ..  . .: -; .: , 1998. . 158.




9


McGuire W. & Hull R.F.C. (eds.). C.G. Jung Speaking. P. 249250.




10


     :      patiens  agens,    ,    ,   ,  ,          .  ,     ,     . <>     :    ( ..     //  . . 303).




11


 .. , ,  [  ]. .: ; : , 1998. . 84.




12


 ..  . . 226227.




13


 .. . .: , 2009. . 255256.




14


    ,      :   ;  , ,     ,         , ..  ,        .         .        ,      ,      ..,            ,       .   ,            ,     .      ,     ,      .               :  ,  ,     ,     ,     .            ( ..  . . 232233).




15


. . 409.




16


Freud S. & Pfister O. Psychoanalysis and Faith: The Letters of Sigmund Freud and Oskar Pfister. London: Hogarth Press and the Institute of Psycho-Analysis, 1963. P. 8687.




17


 .   //   . .: , 1995. . 392.




18


CW 18. 1505.




19


Letters of C.G. Jung: Vol. 2, 19511961. Routledge, 1976. P. 525, to M. Leonard, 5 Dec. 1959.




20


     ,      , ,          .  ,    ,    ,  :    ,    ,    ,      ,    : , .  ,    -  -  .           ,          .     ,        , ,      ,             (Letters 2. P. 525, to M. Leonard, 5 Dec. 1959).      1906     ,   :          ,    ; ,   ,  -,    셻 (CW 2. 895).   ,  ,          .     -,          ,      .        ,   ,    , ,   .     ,       -,     ,   .                 (Jaff A. Was C.G. Jung A Mystic? And Other Essays. Einsiedeln: Daimon Verlag, 1989. P. 89).




21


McGuire W. & Hull R.F.C. (eds.). C.G. Jung Speaking. P. 251.




22


 ..    //   . .: , 1991. . 171. . :  .. Mysterium Coniunctionis. .: -; .: , 1997. . 584.




23


,  :       ,   -      .               .     ,    ,       .  ,      , ,      .




24


 ..     //   . . 100101.




25


 ..    . . 113114.




26


     .  : The Dove in the Consulting Room: Hysteria and the Anima in Bollas and Jung (Hove & New York: Brunner-Routledge, 2003).




27


 ..   . .:  , 2013. . 100.




28


McGuire W. (ed.). C.G. Jung, Notes of the Seminar Given in 1925. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1989. P. 111.




29


 ..       //  . . 58.




30


. . 404.




31


 ..      . . 79.




32


Jung C.G. The Red Book: Liber Novus / Ed. by S. Shamdasani. New York & London, W.W. Norton & Company, 2009. P. 329.




33


   (.). . .




34


   (.). . .




35


 ..    //    . .: , 2023. . 212.




36


 ..    //   :  . .; .: ; Port-Royal, 1997. . 96.




37


Giegerich W. The End of Meaning and the Birth of Man: An Essay about the State Reached in the History of Consciousness and an Analysis of C.G. Jungs Psychology Project // Journal of Jungian Theory and Practice. 2004. Vol. 6. 1. P. 38.




38


CW 18. 632.




39


. . 84.




40


CW 18. 632.




41


White V. God and the Unconscious: An Encounter between Psychology and Religion. London & Glasgow: Fontana Books, 1960. P. 43.


