˸  IV
 


     .      ,       ,       .

       ,   ,        .

   .    ,      ?     ?   ,       ?

   ˸ .   , ,      .  ,      ,   .





 

˸  IV



 IV

 

 I    

 1.  

    .

     ,   .

  .

       ,     :

SERVICE WINDOW SHIFTED  +8 MIN

   .

    ?

    .

    .

    ?

    .

 .

    .

  .

  .

  

CT-185     ,        .

   .

 .

.

.

 .

 .

 .

   ,     .

 ,  -        ,    ,     .

 .

    ,           .

   .

  .

  .

   ,  ,           ,      ETA  .

      .

   .

 ?

        - .

     board,  .

   .

    .

 - .

  .

  

      ,     .

  ,     .

    .

       .

         .

   ,       -    .

,    ,    .

 .

 .

   .

      .

    .

       .

  .

 ,   .

  .

 ?

 .

     ?

 .

     .

   .

    .

  .

 ,   .

 .  ,    .

   .

    .

 ,   .

   .

  

       .

 .

 -      .

     ,       .

       .

 .

 .

       -  .

        .

      ,      ,       .

       .

       .

    ,     ,  .

 .

.

    ,    ?

  ,  .

   .

     .

    .

  ?

 .

   .

 .

 ?

 .

  

        ,   .

 .

 .

 .

 .

   .

   .

 .

 .

 ,      ,          .

 ,   .

  -     .

  .

      .

 .

 .

 CT-185.

 08:41    .

08:43    .

08:44    .

08:45   ETA.

08:46   .

08:47   GREEN.

 .

  .

.

 ?   .

 ?

  .

   .

    .

 .

  .

 .

 CEO   .

 .

         ,   ?

 .

   .

  .

  

       .

 .

 .

 .

  .

 ,  -    ,    ,        .

      ,    .

 ?

      .

  .

  ?

 .

  ?

   .

    .

   .

 .

    , ,    .

  ,    CEO.

    :

        baseline.     .

  .

 .

   .

 .

-    ,   .

  .

   ,      .

  :

     ?

 :

  .   .  .

  ?

 .

  .

     ?

          .

 .

   ,   .    .   .        .

   .

   .

   .

      ?

 .

 .

 .

   .

   .

  .

  ?

 .

 .

     .

      .

 .

   .    .

  .

 ?

      .

 .

      ?

   .

   .

 - .

  

     .

    .

    .

     .

     ,        .

   .

      .

      ,    ,   .

    .

   :

         .

 .

 ?

       B.

    ,  .

   .

 .

  .

 , Atlas        .

  .

.

  ?

 .

  ?

 .

    ?

  .

    .

 ?

     .

  .

  .

 .

  .

Atlas    .

.

.

 ,      .

  .

.

   .

   .

     ,        .

  ,  .

,  .

  

  CT-185     .

      .

    .

 .

   .

   .

    .

      .

  ,    .

     .

   .

   .

    .

  ?

 ?

  .

 .

  .

 .

 ?  .

   .

    .

    .

    .

 .

   ?

 .

   ?

 .

  ?

 .

   ?

        ,    .   ,   .

 .

  .

 ,       .

            :

 ,   .

 ,     ,        .

    .

GREEN.

  .

     .

.

    .

  

 13:18    .

 .

  .

  :

DRIVER REST WINDOW / ARRIVAL CONFLICT

         ,    ,           .

       .

    .

   .

    .

:    .

     .

,  .

       ,       .

   .

 :

OWNER  INTERNATIONAL OPERATIONS.

 CEO.

  .

         ,     .

  .

.

.

 .

   .

   :

   ?

 .

  ?

 .

    ,    .

  :

.

 .

     .

  .

 .

    .

 .

     .

.

.

 ,        ,  ,  .

  .

 :

     ?

 .

   ?

 .

   ?

  .

 .

    .

  .

  .

  .

  .

    .

-  ,        .

   :

     ,      .

  .

.

  -  ,    .

  

 14:05     .

 .

.

     .

   .   ?

    .

 ?

 .

 ?

.

 ?

   .

.

     ETA   .

   .

 .

        , .

 ?

 .

 .

   CEO.

    .

  .

   .

  .

   .

      .

 ?

 ,  CEO    .

    :

   .

    .

  .   .

  :

 .   .

-   .

 .

   ,   .

  ?

       .

  .

  .

   ?

  .

   .

  .  .

   .

  .

        .

 .

   :

SERVICE POINT CHANGED  COMPLETED.

       .

  

    .

 .

 .

   .

-   .

         .

       .

  ?

 .

   ?

  .

 ?

 .

     ?

   .

 .

   .

   .

  .

 .

   .

   .

  .

.

   .

    .

-    .

-    .

-   .

-      ,   .

   ,     .

   ,     -  .

    .

   .

     .

        .

-  .

  .

  .

.

.

Gate.

   ,   ,     .

 .

  -       .

  

       .

    .

  summary    .

 .

.

  .

   .

 safety events.

  .

   escalation   .

    .

   ,       .

   ,    .

      .

   .

  summary    :

.

 :

. .

:

 .

:

.

  .

    .

       .

        , ,    ,      .

   .

   .

 -  .

   .

      ,          .

  .

       .

 -    ,     .

 .

.

  .

:

AUTOMATED FOLLOWING  DATA REVIEW

     .

  .

 CT-185.

    .

     .

.

.

 .

  .

     .

   :

 ;

  ;

  .

 .

  .

  

Summary   .

  .

  .

  .

 :

NO SAFETY EVENT.

:

CONTROLLED FOLLOWING PERFORMANCE WITHIN TEST ENVELOPE.

  .

       .

      .

     -.

 .

-.

   .

     .

        ,     .

 .

   .

.

.

 .

 .

      ,   .

 .

        .

 .

 .

   .

.

   .

 .

 -  ,       :

   ?

     :

    ,   .

    .

          ,   ,      ,     ?

   .

   CT-185    .

 .

GREEN.

  .

   CEO.

    .

        .

  .



 2.  

     .

 ,      .

   .

    ,        .

         .

    .

   .

   ,      .

  .

.

   .

   ,   .

 .

  .

  ,       ,       .

  .

 .

  .

   ,     .

    .

    .

       .

 .

.

   ?

   .

07:42.

:

.

  :

,  .

 :

 9:00.

:

 ,   .

  

     .

    .

 .

  ?

  CEO. .

 ?

  .

  .

  .

 .

   .

  .

   .

  .

    .

   .

  summary.

        test envelope.   .      .       .

  .

 .

  ?

    .

 .

  - ,   .

  .

   ,       .

     .

   .

  .

  .

      ?

  .

 .

  :

   .

 ?

  .   .   . ,         .

 ?

 .

  .

 ?

 .

 .

   ,    .

    .

   software.

     .

    .

    .

-       .

    .

      .

  ,   .

   ?

    .

  .

   ?

   .

    .

  

   ,  .

  .

  .

.

Human factors.

Telemetry.

 .

 .

 review.

 .

 .

   :

   .

 .

  .

 ?

 .        ,    .

  .

      ?

 .   .

  .

    .

 ,    .     .

 .

  ?

   .

 .    ?

  ?

  ,    .

   .

    .

   ?

  .

  ?

      .

   ?

  .

 .

      .

    .

  .    .

 .

   ?

  .

  .

  ,      .

   .

 .

CT-90.

CT-185.

Platform Core.

 safety-.

 .

.

    .

    .

   .

 .

  ,    .

  .

 .

 .

 gate.

    ,  ,     ,    ,     .

   .

    research-?

 .

  ?

   ,    .

   .

  .

     .

:

AUTOMATED FOLLOWING.

:

DRIVER UNDERSTANDING.

:

NEXT TEST.

.

 .

   .

  .

  

   .

 ,    .

 ,       .

  ?

 .

  ?

 .

    .

  .

  .

   .

    .   raw transitions.

  CEO.

    .

     ?

  .    .

     .

  .

 .

  .

 .

   .

     .

    ,  .

   ,       .

      .

 ,    ,   .

    .

    .

  .

  ?

 .

  ?

 .

  ?

.

    .

 ?

       ,       .

   .

    .

   .

 :

   ,      .      .      .

 .   ?

  .

.

   .

 ,   ,        ?

      .

           ?

  .

 .

  .    .

  .

     ?

   .

   .

  , .

 .

 :

    .  .

  .

  

      .

  .

  , .

    CT-185   .

 ,      .

    ,    ,   - -     .

        .

    software.

 .

  .

   .

 ,   .

      .

 .

 .

 ,       .

 ,    ,     ,       ,    .

 ,   .

 .

      .

    .

  .

   .

  ?

  .

 ?

   CEO.    .

 .

 .

      ?

 .

   technical.

   risk framework.

    software.

   .

  ?

.

 .

 .

.

  .

  .

 .

      .

  

    .

        .

 ,  .

  ?

  .

  ?

  .

     .

  ?

 .

  ?

 .

 ?

 .

          .

  .

  .

    ,       ,     ?

 .

  .

   .

    .

    research governance.

 .

 Technical sign-off  . Risk framework  .   .    .

   .

    ?

  .

    .    .

   .

 .

   .

 ?

   .   .    .    ,          ,   .

  ?

      ?

 .

   ,    .

  .

      .

 ,    .

     ,        ?

   .

    .

 ?

    .      ,      .

   .

      ,   .

  .

  .

   .

  .

 ?

    ,    ,     .

   ,    - ?

         .

  ?

   ,    ,   ,   .

 .

   .

   ,    .

  

       .

 .

   , ,        .

  .

 .

.

     .

:

PROJECT.

:

CAPABILITY.

 PROJECT  :

;



;



;



;



;



.

 CAPABILITY:

;



;



;



;



;



?

   .

    .

 .

 ,       .

    .

     ,   , ,          ?

 ?

 ?

 board?

  ?

  ?

  .

      .

  .

  

   .

    .

  ,   .

 .

 .

 .

  research-   .

  .

 . .

 .

 .

   .

 .

 Capability?

 .

   .

  .

 .

  .

    .

 ?

  .

  ?

   .

    ?

 .

  ?

    .

  .

   :

WHY?

  .

   .  .

    ,    ,    ?

     .

       .

 .

   governance.

 Board.

  research.

    .

   ?

     .

 ,       .

  .

     ,      .

 :

    CT-185,    .       ?          ?    ,     ?         ?

  research.

 .

 ?

  .

 ?

  .

 ?

   .

 .

  .

     .

      .

 .

 .

  .

   .

   .

     ,  .

 :

    .

 .

 .

 .

   .   gates.   ,   .

    .

  .

  .

 .

     ,      .

 .

   ?

 .

    ,      ,      ,     .

  ,    ?

 .

 .  .

  .

        .

   .

   ?

  .

  ,    ?

  .

   ?

  .

 .

 .   board?

  .

  .

     .

   .

 .

 .

    .

   .

 .

  .

 .

  .

  .

  

    .

 .

 .

 :

   .

:

   ,   .

     .

    .

.

 .

 .

 .

     .

    .

  :

   ?

  .

Software.

Safety.

Operations.

Training.

Human factors.

Research.

     .

   ,     .

        .

 .

.

?

 :

?

   ?

   .

   .

    .

   .

 :

.

 :

  ,   .

 .

   .

 .

 .

 .

 :

     ,      ?

.

 .

     .

  .

     .

      .



 3.  

        .

  .

  .

    ?

  .

   ?

  ,    .

     .

   .

         .     .

 .

 ,     .

 .

    .

    .  .

  .

  .    .

 .  . .

 ?

  ,     .  .  .  .      .

  .

  .

 .

   .

  .

    ?

   .

     software, safety, , ,    .     .     .

      .

      .

  .

  

     .

:

RESEARCH

:

DEVELOPMENT

:

VALIDATION

     ?

 .

 .

  .

 .  .

 .

 .

 ?

     .

  development.

  research   development.

     ?

  .

   .

  ,   .

 .

 ?

   ,   ,      ,   ,     .

     ?

  safety  .

    RESEARCH  VALIDATION.

       ,       .

     .

  .  .

    .

 .

 ?

 ,  .  .

 .

     ?

 .    ,   .

      .

 ,  .

  

   .

 CT-185   .       .

NORMAL ASSIST.

LIMITED ASSIST.

DRIVER CONTROL.

 .

 .

  .

 ,   .

      .

     .    .     ,     .

  .

  ?   .

  ,       .

  .

 .  ?

    .

  .

 .

     ,   ?

  .

   ,   ?

  .

     ?

   .

 .

      ?

  review.

    ?

  .

    .

  ?

  ,      .

 .

       .

     .

     .

 Technical Council   .

  safety gate.  .   .

 ?

    ,      ,     gate.

 .

      ,      .

    .

   .

 ?

       ,    .

  

   .

,    .

   .

   :

CAN STOP?

 :

CAN SAY NO?

  ?

 .

 .

 Stop     .   :   .   .  .     evidence.       ,     .

   ?

  .

 .

 ,  .

  .

 .

       ,   .

   .

     ?

 .

 . .

  .

 .

  

      .

  .

    .   .    ,  .

   ?

 .

 .

 .   pilot proposal.

  ?

   .

  .

   .

     .  .

 .

       ?

   .

   ?

   .

   .

 .

:

  ,   . Technical Council  .

 Council  stop authority.

   ?

  Council     .

 .

:

  ,    .  ,  .

 Review.

  review?

 .

 .

 .

 .

    .

 .

 ,     .

       .

  ?

      ,   ,     .

  .

 .  ,     .

   ,   .

   .

CAN SAY NO?

    :

WHO REVIEWS NO?

   .

  

         .

  .

.

  ,        .

 ,     .

   owner.

    change record.

 safety-critical    sign-off.

  .

 .

   .

   .

   - ?   .

   .

    ,     .

    ?

    .

 ?

  .

 .

 :

       .    .      .     .         ,       .

  ,   .

   .

 .

   .

  .

 :

 .  feature.

   .

   ?

 .

 .

  

     .

 , .

 ,   ,   .   .  .  .        .

 .

 .  .

 .

     ,   .

     .

 .

      .

       .

 .

 :

      .     . .   .     .       ,   .

    ?

   .

  .

     .

 .

   :  ,    .

   .

 .

 ?

        ,     .

   .

  .

.

 .

  

     .

  .

CAN SAY NO?

WHO REVIEWS NO?

   ,   .

 .

 ?

         ,    ,     ,      .

 ?

     .     .

   .

 .

  .

     ,    .

 .

   board  .

     .

 .

 .

   .

 .

 ?

       ,   ?

 .

     .

   ?

    ,       .

    .

 .

    .

:

  .   .

   :

 .

      .

 .

 .

   .



 4.    

    .

   :

   .

     .

    .

    .     board room.

    .

 :

CAN SAY NO?

WHO REVIEWS NO?

 .

 ?

   ?

       .

  .

  .

  .

 .

 ,     .

  .

  .

    .

      commercial gate.

      .

   .

   .

   , ,    ,    .

 ,   .    ?

    ,   .

    ,      ?

 Board?

  ?

 .

   ?

 .

    ?

 .

  ?

  .

  .

  

      .

COMPANY.

BOARD.

RESEARCH.

VALIDATION.

    .

  ?

   .

.

 ?

   .

.

 ?

    .

.

 ?

  .  .

 .

 IP?

   .

 ,  .

      ,   ,  .

 ,   .

 .

 .

   ,  .

    .

      .

   .

   RESEARCH.

       .

 .

   .

 .

   .

 .

 .

 ?

     ,   ,     .

 .

 .

  .

   .

 .  .

  

   .

 .

 .

 .

    .

    .

      .

         .

   ,       .

    .

  ?

 .   .

    ?

 .

   .

 .

  .

 ,   :       .

 .

   .

 .

 Board .

 .

  .

 .

 .

 .

  ?

   ,  .

    ?

 Review.

 ?

  ?

   ?

 .

 .

 ?

 . .

    .

   .

    .

    .

    .

.

  

    .

  :

ADMINISTRATIVE.

TECHNICAL.

FINANCIAL.

PROGRAM.

REVIEW.

  ,     ?   .

 .

    ?

  technical safety authority,      .

 .

        .

 .

 Program selection?

 .

  ?

 Board   oversight body.

  .

      .     .

 .

 .  .

 .

    ,  .

  .

  .

     governance-.

       .

  .

  ,    .

   .

   .

 .

  ,         .

 .

   board   ,  .

  .

  .

   .

  .

  

 -    .

 ,  ,    ?

  .

 .

 .

    .

 .

   ?

        , ,       .

    .

   .

    .

   .

 .     ?

  .

  ,  research office  .

        ?

 .

   .

 Board.

  .

 .

  .

 .

 ,  credibility    .

 .

       .

 :

CREDIBILITY.

      .

   .

  .

  .

  .

     ,    .

  .

 .

  :

PURPOSE.

  governance    purpose.

 .

  .

   -.

  ,     ,     .

        ?

 .   .

  

      .

    .

    .

    PURPOSE      .

 .

   .

 ?

   .

 ,  .

 .

 .

   .

  ?

 .

      .

 .

   .

  ,  ,  ...

 .

   ?

     .

 .

  .

     .

   .

 ?

   .

   .

   .

    ?

     ,    ,   .

   .

 ?

   ,       .

    .

 .

   .

  .

  

      .

    .

  .

  .

    .

   .

  .

 ,    ,      .

 .

 Budget ceiling  board.

 .

 Technical stop   Technical Council.

  .

 Research     .

 .

 Review    .

 .

    ?

     .

  ?

 .

  CEO ,   .

  .

       board. ,    . ,     .      ,     .

      ?

  governance.

  ?

 KPI, budget, periodic review, audit,     .

 , -   .

 .

   ?

 .

    .

 .

 .

  ,   .

 .

  .

  

      .

     .

 -   .

 -   .

 .

   ,   .

 ?

   - .

   ?

        .

 .

 ?

   .

 ,  .

 .

   .

  ?

     .

  ?

 , .

 ?

  .

 ,      .

  ,     ,       .

 .

  .

    ,      .

   ?

    ,    .

   .

      ?

     .

   .

    .

 ?

     .

     .

 .

 .

 :

    ,    ?

  .

   .

  .

  .

    .

  .

   .

  

    .

 :

  feasibility   .  R&D-.   .       .      .

    .

    .

?

  .

 .

 .

  :

   , .

 :

   .

   :

,   ? ?

   .

 :

 ?

 .

   .

 .

   .

     .

  .

    ?

  .

                 .

     .

      ,  ,       ,  .

 :

.

.

   :

  .



 5.   

     .

  .

 ,    .

  .

   .

   ?

  .

 ?

     ,      ,   .

  .

  .

  .

  .

 .

 ?

  .

  .

 .

  ?

  . ?

  .

 .

.

      ,         .

 .

  . Technical performance     engineering. Risk   . Operations   . Software  . Driver training  .            .

 ?

        .

 ?

 .

   ?

   .

      .

  

 .

     .

    .

   .

  .

 .

     ,         .

 .

      ?

 .

   ?

 .

  .

  .

  .

 .

 .

 ?

     ,   . .

 .

   ,      .          .        ,     ,          ,      .

   .

   .

 ?

 .

 ?

 .

 ?

 .

   .

   ?

 .

  .

  

     .

 .

  ?

          .

  .

Funding.

Data.

People.

IP.

Validation.

Company.

Research.

Board.

 ,   .

    ,      ,   .

 ,   .

  .

           ,   .

    ?

  ,   .     .

 .

   .

 ?

 Research conclusion. Technical stop   .     governance chain.   managerial override.

  board ?

  board     ,    ,   .

    ?

 Review.

 ?

   .

 :

    .

  .

 .

  .

    ,     ?

          .  ,     ,   ,    .

  .

     .

  

   .

,      .

  ?

  .

 ?

  .

 ?

  ,  .

  ?

  .

 ?

 .

 Budget?

   .

   .

  .

    .

  .

 .

      feasibility.

 .

 ?

    ,   .

   .

      .

   .

 .

 :

 .

  ,   .

 core-.

 .

  data governance.

 .

 .

  .

  .

  .

  .

  .

 .

   .

  ,   .

   .

 .

 .

 :

    ?

 .

 ?

          .

   .

   ,   .

  

    .

  ,  feasibility   .

  .

      .

 governance     .

       capability .

   .

 research agenda      .

       .

 :

          .

  .

  .

 ,   .

   .

  ,  .

 ,   .   .      ?

 .

  .

 .

 .

.

.

.

Governance.

.

Budget model.

   .

 research  final validation ,    .

     ,     ,    .

 .

 .

 ?

   .  .

 :

  unilateral managerial override.

 .

 .

   review,   .

    override,   .

   .

    ,     .

   governance,   .

  .   .

  

    NorthBridge.

 ,   .

     .

    ,      ?

 ,   .

 ?

         .   ,  -  .

   .

 .

  .

   .

 .

 .

 .

 .

 IP.

   .

   .

 ,  ,     ,       ?

     .

   .

     .

 .

 .

 .

  .

   .

  feasibility  ownership alternatives.   .

 .

      .

 .

   .

      .

  ,   .

 ?

  .

  :

   .

  ,   .

  .

  

   .

 .

  .

   .

   .

  ?

    .

   ,   .

   .

 ?

   .

   .

           ,          .

    CEO .

 .

   ,    .

 .

       .

  .

      .

   .

 ,   ?

   .

  .

.

             .

 .

     .

  

  feasibility.

  .

 .

  .

           .

     :

purpose;

governance;

leadership profile;

data/IP model;

budget model;

first research program.

  :

KILL CRITERIA.

 .

   ?

 :

 .

   stop criteria?

   stop criteria   .

  kill?

  .   .

 :

    termination criteria.

 .

 .

 .

   .

  

       .

 CT-185.

.

   .

   .

 ?

 ?

   .

   ,   .

   .

   .

  .

   .

  .

  ,    ?   .

    ?

     .    ,  ,    , , .

  ?

     board   .

 .

  .

 .

  .

    .

   ?

  .

     ?

     .

   ?

 .

 .

 ?

  ?

  governance.

  

     .

:

DIRECTOR  REQUIREMENTS

 :

Independent from day-to-day company management.

:

Experience in complex research/engineering institutions.

Ability to build method, not only projects.

Credibility with engineers.

Understands regulation, testing and compliance.

Can work with industry without becoming industry.

Can say no.

 .

   .

:

Can explain why.

 :

Can accept review of own decision.

    .

, .

 .

.

Feasibility approved. Send written scope by tomorrow.

:

And Uri  don't hire yourself.

 :

Too expensive.

:

Not the main problem.

 .

    :

 ?

 .

 , .

 .

    .

  .

      .

     ,     ,  .

     :

 ,       .

.

  .



 6.  

    .

   .

 ,     .

          ,   ,         .

    .

  .

    .

   .

       .

 ,    .

   .

    ?

 . ?

 .

      .

  .

         .

 .

  ?

      .

 ,  .

 .

  .

  ?

 .

  .

     .

  

  .

,  .

  ,      .

  ?   .

 .

   .

    .

    .

    .

  .

            .

 .

 .

 ?

       .

   ?

   :     ,   .

   .

    ?

   .   .

  ?

 .

       .

 , .

 .

   .

  ?

 .      ,     ,     ,    ,     .

 .

   .

    .

 .

   .

  .

  .      .

  

       .

 .

 .

  .

  .

    .

        ,      .

    .

   .

     ,      .

  .

 .

      ,   .

 .

 ,   ?

 .

   .

 .

   .

 .

 . , CEO.

      .

 .

   .

      ,     .

 .  ?

  .

      ,    .

  .

     ,      .

   ?

  .

.

 .

 ?

 .

  .

  .   .   ,  .

  .

 .

 ?

          ,    ,   .

   .

      ?

 .

 . .

  

    feasibility.

 .

Board        .

  ?   .

   .

 .

   .

 .

 .

  .

     .

 research, development  validation.

    .

 .

    .

 .

 .

    ?

     governance-.

  .

 .

    ?

       .

    .

 ?

    .

    ,   .

  .

   .

  .

  ,      .

  

    .

 .

.

.

 .

 .

.

 .

  .

     ,  ,  .

    ?

  .

    ?

 .

    ?

      .

Ÿ   .

  .

  ?

 .

 .

 .

  .

 ?

  ,        .

  .

 .

 .

 .

 .

     ,    .         ,    .

   .

  ?

   ,   ,     .

  .

 .

  

      .

.

  .

  ?

 .

  ?

         ?

 .

 .

   .

    .         .

 ?

 .

.

 .

 ?

  ,   .

 ?

   .

  .

 .

 ?

    CEO.

 .

 .

   ,  ,     .

   .

 .

  ?

 .

 .

  .

  :      ,    .          ,     ...

  .

   .

 .

 .

 .

 .

     .

    .

        .

 .

     R&D.

 .

   .

 research  business goals.

 time-to-market.

 .

 -  .

  :

NO.

  .

  

   .

 ?   .

 ?

 .

 .

  ?

       .

  .

  .

   ?

   ,  .

 ?

      research  .

    ?

 .

 .

   .

 .

  :

 ,  ?

 ?

      ,   ,     ,    .

      .

  ?

   .

      .

 .

  .

 .

    .

  .

    .

     .

        .



 7.   

    .

   .

    .

       ,   .

   .

  .

 :

 ,  , ,   .

 ,   .     ,     ?

    .

   ?

 .

  .

  ?

 , ,    .

   .

   .

  :

  ?

  .

  ?

    .     .

 , .

 .

   .

   .

 .

 .

  .

  

     pipeline .

 ?

  ,      .

   .

  .

R&D portfolio.

Product acceleration.

Technology transfer.

Commercialization.

Stage gates.

  .

 .

 ,   ,          ,        .

      .

    ?

  .

      ?

 .

    ,    .

   :

   .

 .

  .

   ?

  ,       commercialization.

 .

 .

 .

  

   testing, compliance  conflict of interest.

   ,       ,    .

       .

     ?   .

   .

             telemetry?

   .

 .

.

.

.

.

  ,      ,    .

     .

    :

  .

 ?

   .

 ?

 .

    .

  .

 .

   .

 .

   ,   .

       .

 .

 .

 :

INDEPENDENCE WITHOUT ISOLATION.

  .

  .

  

      .

 .

 .

  ?

 .

 ?

 .

 ,  .

      .

    .

 Feasibility.

   .

   .

 .

   ,           .

 .

  ,    validation.

 .

   ,   review.

 .

        R&D.

 .

   ?

 .

   .

 .

 .

   .

 ?

  .

 .

    .

   .

  ?

     .     .

  ?

    ,   compliance.  .

 ?

  .

  ?

   .

   .

 .

  

   .

  .

  .

.

 .

 .

   .

    .

      test-   .

   research governance      validation.

     ,       .

 .

  .

      ?

   .

     ,  .

  ,      .

  ?

   .

   .

  .

 :

 .

   .

 .

  ?

  .

    ?

 .

  

   .

.

   .

 .

  ,    .

 :

   ,   .

    ?

           .

  .

.

  .

 .

   .

   .

   .

.

  .

  .

Human factors.

Automation.

Safety.

.

  .

   .

 research  final validation ,   .

 .

 :

  governance.

    .

.

.

Research agenda.

 governance.

   .

      .

 ?

           .

  .

   .

  

   .

  .

   ?

 Board   .

    ?

 Board.

   ?

  .

  ?

  .

   ?

  .   .

   ?

  .

 IP?

  .

    research conclusion?

   .

  .

  review?

  .

 ?

     .

  .

 .

  .

  ?

 ?

 .

   .

        .

 :

     ?

     .

    ?

  .

 :

    ?

  .

        ?

    ,      .

   .

 ? ? ? ? ? Validation?   .

 :

     .

     ,  ?

 :

      ,     .

    .

   .

     .

  

    .

   .

 .

 ,    , :

  ,     .

 .

  R&D.

  .

 .

 .

   .

   .

  ?

 ?

  governance.

  .

 .

     ?

    ,    ,  ,          ,      .

  .

.

  ?

 Personnel authority.

 ?

 . .

   ?

  CEO    ,     ,   .

      ,   ?

     .

     ?

   ,   .

   .

 .

.

  

   .

   governance draft.

  ?

  ,    .

     ?

  .       ,      .

 .

 .

   .

 .

  .

  .

 ?

    ,      ,      .

 .

   .

 .

 .

 ?

  .

 ,  .

   .

   .

  .

 .

  .

    ,    .

  .



 8.   

  governance draft   .

  .

 .

  .

  .

    .

INDEPENDENT RESEARCH INSTITUTE

 INDEPENDENT .

:

  ,    .

  .

   ?

  .

   .

 ,  .

 :

FOUNDER ROLE.

 :

Founder participates in strategic agenda setting.

 :

 ,   agenda   influence on conclusions.

:

CEO access to research teams.

:

       .

:

Personnel.

  .

  .

 .

   .

  

     .

    .

   ,     ,   .

     .

    .

 ?

  .

  .

  .

   .

 .

    flagship research program.

 .

    .

   .

 :

   .

 .

 :

     .

 .

 CEO   strategic agenda.

 .

 Board  .

 .

           ?

 :

 .

  ?

.

.

 .

  ,     .

  

   personnel authority.

    core-      CEO.

  .

 ,    .

          .

    ,   .  Compliance  . Conflict check  .         .

      ?

   ,     .

  .

      .

 .

 .

    .

 :

   hires  secondment.   hires       headcount  compensation bands.  secondment     . CEO    veto,   conflict/compliance process.

   .

    ?

 .   .

  .

 .

    .

 .

      ,   .

      .

  

  .

      board,   .

   .

   CEO.

  .

  charter.

 .

           .

  governance chain?

 .

 ?

 .    .

  .

        .

   confidential data?   .

  .

 IP?

  .

 Commercial sensitivity?

      .    .

 .

 :

    ?

   .

  review.

 ?

  .

  .

    .

  board?

   . Board   , ,  ,  review.      .

 .

   .

  .

 ?

   ,    .

   .

  

       .

Automatic following.

     flagship.

 .

 ?

     .

  .

 .    ,        .

    .

 .

    .

       .

 .

   ?

    :       ?   ,    :            ?

    .

 .    ,    CT-185?

  .

  ?

  .

  ?

 .

 .

   .

     .

          .

   mission     .

     ?

 Periodic program review.

 Board?

 Governance body,       .

   .

  ?

 .    .

 .

  

  .

   .

 ,    .

    -,    .

CT-185    .

.

.

.

.

 .

      .

   .

   ,     ,  ,    .

  .

 ?

 .

 ?

  .

  .

   .

     research question.

 .

    ?

   ,  .

   ?

     .

   .

    ,     .

 .

      .

 .

  .

   .

 .

   CT-185.

  .

 ?

        ?

 .

  ?

  .

 .

  .

  

     .

 ,       ?

   .

.

 ,   .

 .

     ,        .     .       .

     periodic review  ?

 .

   audit ?

 .

  review ?

  review       ,  CEO .

   ?

       .

  .

.

 .

 :

   board ,     ,    mission?

   governance failure .

    .

 .

       ?

 .

   .

   ,    .

    .

      ?

 ,    .

.

  

   .

      ,    .

CEO    .

CEO    research conclusion.

Director   final validation authority  ,     .

Board    mission,    evidence.

Negative conclusion  written basis.

Review   basis, method, conflict  process.

Review    managerial override.

Program agenda    : ,  ,     .

        - .

  .

  .

  ,   .

   .

         .

   .

   .

  .

 .

 .

  

      :

MISSION CHARTER  DRAFT 0.3

 .

  .

  .

       .

  ?

 .

 .

   ,       board.

    ,         .

 .

 .

  .

 ?

        ,      ,   .

  .

         ,    , .

   .

 :

 .     KPI:     .

 .

  .

 - .

.

  

       .

Experience.

Method.

Credibility.

Compliance.

Can say no.

Can explain why.

Can accept review.

   :

DOES NOT NEED TO BE MY OPPONENT TO BE INDEPENDENT.

.

 :

AND DOES NOT NEED TO BE MY ALLY.

.

    .

   .

       ,      .

  .

,      .



 9.  

   :

   .

   .

   .

  .

   .

  .

   .

CT-185 telemetry.

Driver observations.

Service records.

Client route data.

Industrial partner configuration data.

Insurance incident fields.

Research annotations.

      .

 ,   .    .

   ,  ,   ,            .

  .

  .

 ,        .

   ?   .

   .

   .

      .    ,      .

.

     .     .

.

   .         ,      .

.

  .

  .

 .

 .

 .

  ,   .  ,    :          .

  :

 .

   .

    .

   .

.

   .

  

     .

OWNED.

LICENSED.

PROGRAM-LIMITED.

NO ACCESS WITHOUT NEW AGREEMENT.

    .

    ,   .

  ?   .

   .

.

.

.

 .

 .

Software licenses.

    .

      .

     ,        .

 ,     ,       ,    .

 .

    .

 .

   .

   .

 .

     governance  .

 Governance   .

     .

   .

      .

  .

  

     IP.

 ,    .

.

 ,   ,          handover    .

 .

   ?

 .

  .

 ?

    .

   ?

  .

    ?

    .

   ?

   .

    ?

 .

 .

 .  .

 .

     .

 :

     ,    .

     ,    ,    .

 .

  .

   .

 .

    ,     ,    .

  

    .

COMPANY-SPONSORED RESEARCH.

JOINT PROGRAM.

INSTITUTE-INITIATED RESEARCH.

     IP.

 company-sponsored         .

 joint        .

 institute-initiated          ,     .

 .

   .

 ,   .

   .

 .

   ?

  .

   .

    ?

  .     ,   .

 .

   .

   .

  .

  .

  .

 :

  credibility ,      .

 .

 .

     .

   ,    .

   ,    .

   .

     .

    .

  

      .

 ,    - .

   :     ,  ,     .

   .

Production.

Test.

Research copy.

.

  .

    ,   .

  ?

   .

       ?

    .

   .

 .

     .

       research copy?   .

 ,   .        ,   derived data,  ,   ,     .

 :

      .

 ?

  .

 ?

  .

   .

    ?

  ,  .

 .

  

    .

   .

 .

 .

  software .

    .

    .

    .

   ?   .

 :

  .

 ?

      .

 .

Raw vehicle telemetry.

Client operational context.

Driver research responses.

Research annotations.

Derived metrics.

Method.

Final conclusion.

 .

  .

   .

     .

    ,   .

  .

  

    Data & Asset Access Draft.

  .

  .

   ,        ,    .

        .

        .

         .

   purpose  .

      .

Research environment   production.

 derived data    .

IP    ,     .

   .

  ?

 .

    .

 ?

 :

      .

 .

 .

  .

 -.

  

     .

    .

 ?

 .

    personnel.

    .

   .

 .

      .     ,    .

 .

          ,         ,   .

 , secondment limits.

 .   .

 .

 :

           ,     .

 .

 .

  .

         .

      .

         .

  

   draft .

    :

    , ,   ,       ?

  .

 :

 .

  :

 .  .

:

   08:00.

   .

.

 .

, ,       .

  .

       .

   ,    ,     .



 10.   

   .

   .

   .

  .

 .   .

  .

  .

  .

   .

 NorthBridge     .

 .

  .

   .

    .

   Data & Asset Access Draft.

   feasibility.    , , ,   , ,    .

 .

  NorthBridge      ?

        .

    .

   ?

   .

    .

   .

  

     ,   .       , ownership .        governance  .

  ?

 .

  .

 .

     .

  .

 ,    .     ,     - ?

   :

    .

   .

 .

    :        ,   .

    ?

 ,     governance.

   .

    ?

  .

 .

 :

   .   .

  .

 .

   .

  

   .

:    .

.

ĸ.

  .

:  .

  .

      .

:            .

.

:        .

   .

, ,      .

 .

  ?

  ,   .

 Feasibility,   .

 .

        .

 .

   .

  

     ownership.

    governance.

   .

         managerial override    .

          ,   .

 .

 ,       .

 .

    .

  .

   .

    .

   .

.

 operating budget.

 .

 .

              mission.

 .

    .

 :

 .

 .

    .   .

   .

        ,    .

   .

 .

.

  

 ,   ,  NorthBridge    .      ,     ,            .

    ,   .

 .         .

   .

 :

 Conflict rules.

 Non-compete?

 ,   .        ,  credibility  .

   Atlas?

    .

   .

  Atlas?

 ,    Atlas   .

 :

 .

  . .

 .

     confidential assets     .

    ?

    mission  conflict policy.

   .

   ?

  .

 ?

     ,       ,    ,        .

   .

 .

 .

        .

 :

      .

  

     .

    .

Company-sponsored         .

Mission research    .

    .

   conflict review.

 :

    ?

 Board    ,   .

     .

    . Research conclusion  .

         ?

   .

 .

 .

 :

   .

   ?   ?

 .   commitment    review points   .

  .

   .

    ?

 .

 .

 :

    .

  

     .

 .

 .

.

         .

        .

Budget review  mission,  , ,         .

 .

  .

 ,   .

     .

  .

  .

  ownership?

 :

      feasibility.

   .

 ?

 .

   ,      ?

     mission         .

   ?

   .

 .

 .

 .

  .

  

   .

 .

 .

  ,  NorthBridge    ?

 .

       .

 .

    .

  .

  .

 ...

  .

 .

  .

 ,   .   ?

 .

,     .

    product gate.

     .

  ,        .

 .

  , human factors,    .

         ?

   .

 .

     .

  

    :

         charter.

 .

   .

     .

Data/IP.

Funding.

Ownership alternatives.

Director authority.

Board access.

Review mechanism.

Personnel.

 research program.

   .

 .

      .

      ,     .

   .

       .

.

.

  safety-critical systems.

  :

   core technical research.  .

  :

 .    core team       .

 .

    .

   ,      - .

  .

    :

.

 .

 .

  .

    .

    .



 11.  

   .

  ?

  .

   .

   .

  ?

 .

     .

     .

  .

   .

 .

 .

  ,   .    validation engineer.  .         .

 ?

   core research  ,      .

  .

  ?

      .

  .

  .

  ?

   ,  .

  ?

 .          core-.

   .

 .

  .

 .

   .

 .

.

    ?

.

 ,   .

   .

  

     .

 .

      ,   .

  .

     .

  .

 .

  ?

  .

  validation background.   research.      ,    .

     field anomalies.

 .

 Human-machine systems.

 .

   CT.

       .

 ?

          ,      .

 .

  .

  .

 .

   .

 ,   .      .

 .

   ?

 .

 , .

  .

 ?

       .     .

 .

  ?

       .     ,  CEO   .

 .

 .

  ?

      .

 ?

 ,       -  .

 .

    review .

   ,   .

 ,    .

    .

  

    .

  .

      ,  .

    .

Core team hires:

Director owns professional selection.

CEO may propose candidates.

Proposal does not create preference.

Rejection must have documented professional basis.

For key roles, a second qualified reviewer may challenge basis.

Challenge does not equal override.

 .

      .

 :

     .

  ?

    .

 .

   .

 :         ,       .

     :

 .

   .

  .

  .

.

  

            Mission Charter   governance package.

  .

  .

 ,     .

  .

  .

      .

  .

 .

 .

  research network  .

     .

  .

  ?

 .

   .

  .

  .

     .

    .

    .

 .

  .

  

       facilities.

   ?

 .

 .

 ?

  ,     .

   .

 - ,    .

  .    .

 .

Facilities    .

Research terminals.

   .

       .

 .

   .

    .

   ,   ,     .

  

    access matrix.

 .

 CEO unrestricted access to premises?

 .

   .

   ,  .

     ?

 .

 ?

  ,          .

  :

      .

 .

  .

  .

   .

   .

   ,   .

     ,   .

 .

.

.

  

     .

 .

  coordinator  data administration.

 ?

             .

 .

    technical research.

   .

     .

   .

  :

QUESTIONS BEFORE PRODUCTS.

 .

  .

  .

 .

     :

HOW DOES THE DRIVER KNOW WHAT THE SYSTEM EXPECTS NOW?

   .

    pilot.

   .

       .

    .

 .

  .

  .

    .

  

   .

  .

  .

   Mission Charter draft.

    separation of research and validation.

  ?

 ,   .

  .

 .

 .

 ?

      .

  .

  research      exploratory testing.

 .

  final validation   ,     .

 .

    ?

   .

 :

 Open item.

 .

 .

  .

 . .

  .

   ,    .

  .

      .

 ,   .

  

    Technical & Safety Council.

      .

,          .

  ,  research conclusion   safety approval.

  ,  technical authority          .

  .

  .

 Council     safety-critical ,   .

 .

         ,       product architecture,   .

 .

   .

   ,  -   ?

 .

   .

   .

  

      .

RESEARCH CONCLUSION.

TECHNICAL VALIDATION.

OPERATIONAL RELEASE.

    .

  .

  .

   .

  .

 .

      .

 .

    .

 .

 .

 ,   .

    .

       ?

     .

,     ,   .

 .

  

        .

 .

    IT  research segment.

    .

    .

 .

 .

     .

  .

     .

  .

  .

   .

     .

   .

 .

  :

     technical research.  .  .

 :

        Word.

 :

.

     .

    .

    .



 12. 

   ,     .

 ?   .

        .

 ,   .

   .

    .

  ,   .

   governance.

   .

 .

     :

RESEARCH CONCLUSION.

TECHNICAL VALIDATION.

OPERATIONAL RELEASE.

    .

     ,        .

 .

  .

.

  

    .

  .

  .

     technical authority,   .        ,    .

 .

 Safety-critical technical transition  sign-off  .

  .

 .

 :

     ,       ?

   .

 .

     ,       .

   human factors issue.

     ?

   .

     .

  

   :

STOP AUTHORITY ? FINAL TRUTH.

 .

 ?

 .

 .

 :

 .

 :

 Stop      .    .

 ,    safety-relevant research finding...

  ,   .

 .

  threshold.

 ?

     .

   .

       ?

 .

    CEO?

  .

  .

  .

  

    .

    stop?

 ,      stop request    .

 ,   ,       .

   ,   ,    ,        .

     ,   ,  stop authority    .

     .

   ?

  .

:

PLAUSIBLE SAFETY RELEVANCE.

REPRODUCIBLE OR MATERIAL.

NO ADEQUATE EXISTING CONTROL.

  ?   .

  .

  :

BASIS DOCUMENTED.

 .

 .

 .

 .

 .

 .  - ?

 ,   .   .

  

   .

  stop?

 ,   .

 CEO.

 board .

  .

  .

Research finding.

Formal stop.

Evidence review.

Corrective action or clarified control.

Independent validation where required.

Release decision.

   release?   .

 :

   ,  .

  .

     .

 :

  stop   human factors, final closure     engineering.

 .

   human factors authority.

  ,   .  Authority   ,   .

 .

     .

     .

  

    Council.

    ,    .       .

    research  , engineering    , operations   ,  CEO ...

   .

 ?

 .

  .

        .

    .

 ,   .

    .

 .

    formal stop, operations  .

    stop ?   .

    release.   .

   .

 .

   .

  .

  .

  

   Technical & Safety Council.

  ,      .

   .

 :

technical authority;

research representative;

risk/governance;

operational owner,    ;

  ,  .

CEO  .

     .

Board   escalation  governance, ,  .

  ,       .

 .

    CEO.

 :

    .

   .  .

 :

   .

  

     .

 .

 .

  operations.

      automatic following   .

  .

    test envelope.

 .

 Technical readiness .

 :

  research readiness?

   ?

     ?

  ,   .    .

       ,   ,     .

   .

  stop?

 .

 ?

      safety risk.  ,     .

 .

 .

  .

 .

  

     .

     stop.

  research concern  safety concern.

    :

  .

 :

 .

   ,        .

  .

  .

   .

     .

   .

   .

   ?   .

 :

  human factors .

    .

 , .

   ?

     .

 :

     .

 .

   .

  

  Council .

     .

 :     ,          .

   .

  governance.

  :

SUBJECT TO CHARTER APPROVAL.

 .

     ?

   .

  .

 .

  .

 .     ,   .

  .

   .

 .

  

   .

    ?

 .

  ?

 .

  .

     authority  ego.

 .

  .

  ?

   .

 .

    :

HUMAN FACTORS  REQUIRED.

     .

   ,    .

     .

     .

  charter      .



 13.   

 -     .

 ,   .

 ?

  .

    CT-185    .

   ,   , ,   ,  ,    .

  ?

 .

  .

 ?

      ,    ,     .

   .

    ,      .

  .

     .

  

      ,   .

    .

    .

  .

 :

     ?

 .

    ?

.

   ?

 .

    awareness?

  .

    ?

  .

 .

 ?

  .

 ?

   .

 Haptic?

 .

    degraded external communication?

   .

   .

 Local telemetry , reserve channel    .

   ?

 .

 .

 .

   .

   .

  

   .

  CT-185   .

    .

 .

 ,       automatic following support.    ?

  .

.

    ?

 .

   ,        ?

  .

   ?

.

   ?

   ,     ,     ?

 .

    ?

   .

 :

   ?

  .

      ?

 .

 ...  .

   ?

  .

    .

  

   .

 .

  .

  .

   degraded state  :

  ,     .

   ?

    .

 :

 ?

  ,  .

  :

         .

     :

 .

  .

 .

.

 .

 .

  ,  .

   .

   .

  

   :

    .

 :

 .

   .

 ?

         .




  .


   .

   ,     (https://www.litres.ru/book/igor-gutin-34109518/liogkii-put-iv-74637224/)  .

      Visa, MasterCard, Maestro,    ,   ,     ,  PayPal, WebMoney, ., QIWI ,       .


